the preconventional reasoning has sometimes been described as

Championisme authors

2 min read

·

21-10-2024

28

0

Share

Beyond Right and Wrong: Exploring the Preconventional Stage of Moral Reasoning

The preconventional stage of moral reasoning, a concept introduced by developmental psychologist Lawrence Kohlberg, is often described as the stage of self-interest and immediate consequences. But what does this truly mean, and how does it impact our understanding of moral development?

What is Preconventional Reasoning?

Before diving deeper, let's define our terms. Preconventional reasoning, the first stage of Kohlberg's theory of moral development, is characterized by a focus on personal consequences and external authority. Individuals in this stage primarily judge the morality of an action based on whether it will lead to punishment or reward, regardless of underlying principles or societal norms.

"What's in it for me?" - The Core of Preconventional Reasoning

To understand preconventional reasoning, we can analyze the two substages within it:

1. Stage 1: Punishment-Obedience Orientation: Here, individuals primarily avoid actions that lead to punishment, as they perceive punishment as a sign of wrongness. This is often seen in young children who might avoid stealing cookies not because it's morally wrong, but because they fear getting caught.

2. Stage 2: Instrumental Relativist Orientation: In this stage, individuals focus on what they can gain from an action. "You scratch my back, I'll scratch yours" becomes the guiding principle. Moral decisions are made based on what provides the best benefit or advantage, often in a transactional sense.

Examples in Action

• A child refuses to share his toy with a friend because he wants to keep it for himself. (Stage 2 - "It's mine, and I want to play with it").

• A teenager decides not to speed because he knows he might get a ticket. (Stage 1 - "If I get caught, I'll be in trouble").

Beyond the Simple "Good vs. Bad" Binary

Preconventional reasoning, while seemingly simplistic, is crucial in understanding early moral development. It lays the foundation for more sophisticated moral reasoning, where individuals learn to consider the perspectives of others and internalize societal norms. This stage is not about "good" or "bad" but rather about understanding consequences and personal gain.

Moving Beyond Preconventional Reasoning

As individuals mature, they typically progress through higher stages of moral reasoning, developing a more nuanced understanding of right and wrong. This evolution involves considering social norms, fairness, and empathy, leading to a more complex and ethical perspective.

Key Takeaways:

• Preconventional reasoning emphasizes personal consequences and external authority, focusing on what is beneficial for the individual.
• It is a crucial stage in moral development, laying the groundwork for more advanced moral reasoning.
• Understanding preconventional reasoning helps us better grasp the moral reasoning of children and adolescents, and can inform how we guide their moral development.

Further Exploration

• You can explore the works of Lawrence Kohlberg, especially his "Moral Development and Education," for a deeper dive into preconventional reasoning and his stages of moral development.
• Consider examining the role of cultural influences on preconventional reasoning and how different societies may have different understandings of right and wrong at this stage.

Remember: While preconventional reasoning is a crucial aspect of moral development, it is not the only stage. As we grow and mature, our moral reasoning evolves, reflecting a more complex and nuanced understanding of the world around us.