speed table vs speed bump

Championisme authors

3 min read

·

29-09-2024

62

0

Share

When it comes to controlling vehicle speed in residential areas, schools, and commercial districts, two popular solutions are speed tables and speed bumps. While both serve a similar purpose, they have distinct features, advantages, and disadvantages. This article delves into the differences between speed tables and speed bumps, analyzes their effectiveness, and explores practical considerations for their implementation.

What are Speed Tables?

Definition

Speed tables are elevated areas of a roadway, typically longer and flatter than speed bumps, designed to reduce vehicle speed. They usually span the width of the road and are designed to allow for a smooth transition for both vehicles and pedestrians.

Benefits of Speed Tables

1. Vehicle Compatibility: Their gradual incline and decline allow for more comfortable traversing by a wider range of vehicles, including larger trucks and emergency vehicles.
2. Pedestrian Safety: Speed tables often include crosswalks and pedestrian signals, enhancing safety for pedestrians.
3. Durability: Speed tables, often made with concrete, can withstand significant wear and tear from traffic.

What are Speed Bumps?

Definition

Speed bumps are shorter, more abrupt elevations in the roadway, typically ranging from 2 to 4 inches high and often 12 to 14 feet wide. They are primarily used in parking lots and residential areas to slow down vehicles.

Benefits of Speed Bumps

1. Effective Speed Control: Their abrupt nature forces drivers to slow down significantly, resulting in a more immediate reduction in speed.
2. Cost-Effectiveness: Generally less expensive to install than speed tables, making them an attractive option for budget-conscious municipalities.
3. Simplicity: Easy to install with minimal infrastructure changes.

Key Differences Between Speed Tables and Speed Bumps

Effectiveness: Speed Tables vs. Speed Bumps

Traffic Calming

Studies have shown that both speed tables and speed bumps can effectively reduce vehicle speeds. However, speed tables typically achieve a moderate reduction in speed, while speed bumps can significantly reduce speed to below 10 mph.

Noise Considerations

Speed bumps can create noise as vehicles traverse them, potentially leading to complaints from residents. On the other hand, speed tables are less noisy due to their gradual incline, making them preferable in quiet neighborhoods.

Emergency Response

A common concern is how these traffic calming measures affect emergency response times. Speed bumps can slow down emergency vehicles, while speed tables, due to their design, allow for a quicker passage, which can be crucial in emergencies.

Practical Examples

Case Study: Residential Area

In a suburban residential area, local authorities implemented speed bumps in high-traffic zones. While effective in reducing speeds, complaints about noise led them to consider speed tables. After a pilot program, residents reported improved safety for children walking to school without the noise issues associated with speed bumps.

Case Study: Commercial District

In a busy commercial district, planners opted for speed tables due to their capacity to slow down traffic while allowing larger delivery trucks and emergency vehicles to navigate easily. This solution not only enhanced safety for pedestrians but also maintained the flow of traffic, proving to be a successful compromise.

Conclusion

When deciding between speed tables and speed bumps, it’s crucial to consider the specific needs of the area, including traffic volume, types of vehicles, noise level, and pedestrian safety. While both options serve to calm traffic effectively, speed tables provide a more versatile solution for various contexts, especially in mixed-use environments.

By choosing the right traffic calming measure, communities can enhance safety while ensuring a smooth flow of traffic. Whether opting for a speed table or a speed bump, it's important to engage with residents and consider their feedback to ensure the chosen solution meets the needs of the community.

References

• ScienceDirect Articles on Traffic Calming: Retrieved from ScienceDirect

Further Reading

For those looking to implement these strategies, consider reviewing local traffic regulations and reaching out to traffic engineers for tailored solutions to meet your community's needs.