robinson map projection advantages and disadvantages

Championisme authors

2 min read

·

19-10-2024

53

0

Share

The Robinson Projection: A Compromise for World Maps

The Robinson projection, created by Arthur H. Robinson in 1963, is a popular compromise projection often seen in atlases and textbooks. It aims to balance distortion across the globe, striking a middle ground between the accuracy of conformal projections and the area-preserving properties of equal-area projections. But does it truly succeed, and at what cost?

Understanding the Robinson Projection:

The Robinson projection is classified as a pseudocylindrical projection, meaning it presents the world on an oval shape resembling a globe. It's neither conformal (preserving angles and shapes) nor equal-area (preserving relative sizes), but rather a compromise projection aiming to minimize distortions across the entire map.

Advantages:

• Visually Appealing: The Robinson projection is visually pleasing, offering a balanced representation of the world with minimal distortion. This makes it ideal for general-purpose maps where aesthetics play a significant role.
• Reduced Area Distortion: Compared to other projections, the Robinson projection minimizes area distortion across the map, particularly in the mid-latitudes. This is especially important for representing continents like Europe and Asia, where area discrepancies can be significant in other projections.
• Widely Used and Recognizable: Its widespread use in atlases, textbooks, and other educational materials has led to its familiarity and recognition. This makes it accessible to a broad audience, facilitating understanding and interpretation.

Disadvantages:

• Not Truly Conformal or Equal-Area: The Robinson projection's compromise nature means it doesn't completely excel in either shape or area preservation. This leads to noticeable distortions, particularly near the poles and along the edges of the map.
• Distorted Shapes and Distances: While it strives for balance, the Robinson projection still distorts shapes and distances, especially near the poles. The Greenland effect, where Greenland appears larger than South America on the map, is a prominent example of this distortion.
• Limited Use for Specific Applications: Its compromises make it unsuitable for applications requiring high accuracy, such as navigation, surveying, or cartographic analysis.

Examples and Applications:

The Robinson projection's aesthetic appeal and moderate distortions have led to its widespread adoption in various applications:

• Atlases and Textbooks: The Robinson projection is the standard for many world maps in atlases and textbooks, aiming to provide a visually appealing and reasonably accurate representation of the globe.
• General-Purpose Maps: The Robinson projection is commonly used in general-purpose maps, such as wall maps, posters, and educational materials.
• News and Media: Its familiar shape and moderate distortions make it a popular choice in news media and publications for presenting global data and trends.

Conclusion:

The Robinson projection is a valuable compromise for general-purpose world maps, offering a visually pleasing and moderately accurate representation of the globe. Its widespread use and familiar appearance make it accessible and understandable. However, its compromises on shape and area preservation limit its suitability for specialized applications requiring high accuracy. As with any projection, understanding its strengths and weaknesses is crucial for interpreting map information effectively.

Further Considerations:

• Alternative Projections: Exploring alternative projections, such as the Winkel Tripel or the Mollweide projection, can provide insights into different approaches to mapping the world.
• Projection Aware Applications: Utilize cartographic software and tools designed to manage projection complexities, allowing for accurate visualization and analysis.

References:

• Robinson, A. H. (1963). A new map projection for general use. The American Cartographer, 10(1), 1-6. Source: sciencedirect.com

Note: This article draws on information and concepts from the cited source but provides additional analysis, examples, and applications to enhance understanding and engagement.