john locke two treatises of government summary

Championisme authors

4 min read

·

10-12-2024

45

0

Share

John Locke's Two Treatises of Government, published anonymously in 1689, is a cornerstone of Western political philosophy. It profoundly influenced the development of liberal thought, significantly shaping the American and French Revolutions. While the First Treatise largely refutes Robert Filmer's patriarchal theory of divine right monarchy, the Second Treatise is far more influential, laying out Locke's vision of a just and limited government based on natural rights. This article will summarize the key arguments of the Second Treatise and analyze their enduring impact.

I. The State of Nature and Natural Law:

Locke begins by outlining the "state of nature," a hypothetical condition preceding organized government. Contrary to Hobbes's depiction of a brutal "war of all against all," Locke argues that the state of nature is governed by natural law. This law, discernible through reason, dictates that all individuals possess inherent rights, including the right to life, liberty, and property. As expressed in the Second Treatise, Chapter 2, Section 6: "The state of Nature has a law of Nature to govern it, which obliges every one: and Reason, which is that Law, teaches all Mankind, who will but consult it, that being all equal and independent, no one ought to harm another in his Life, Health, Liberty, or Possessions."

Analysis: Locke's concept of natural law differs significantly from Hobbes'. While Hobbes believed human nature is inherently selfish, leading to a chaotic state of nature requiring a powerful sovereign, Locke posits that humans are capable of reason and cooperation. The state of nature, for Locke, is not necessarily pleasant, but it is not inherently lawless. Disputes can arise, however, necessitating a social contract to resolve them peacefully.

Example: Consider two farmers disputing ownership of a piece of land. In Locke's state of nature, they would ideally resolve the conflict through reason and appeal to natural law (e.g., first possession, evidence of cultivation). However, the absence of an impartial arbiter can lead to violence. This highlights the need for a government to establish clear property rights and a system of justice.

II. The Social Contract and the Purpose of Government:

To escape the inconveniences of the state of nature, individuals voluntarily enter into a social contract, forming a government. This contract is not a surrender of all rights but rather a delegation of certain powers to the government for the protection of remaining rights. The primary purpose of government, according to Locke, is to protect individual rights, particularly the right to property. This is detailed in Chapter IX, where he elaborates on the acquisition of property through labor.

Analysis: Locke's social contract theory emphasizes consent and limited government. Unlike Hobbes's absolutist model, where the sovereign holds unlimited power, Locke advocates for a government accountable to its citizens. The government's legitimacy stems from the consent of the governed, implying the right to revolution if the government violates the terms of the contract.

III. The Right to Revolution:

A crucial element of Locke's political philosophy is the right of the people to resist tyranny. If the government consistently fails to uphold its end of the social contract—by violating natural rights or acting arbitrarily—the people have the right to alter or abolish it. This is highlighted in Chapter XIX, where he discusses the dissolution of government.

Analysis: Locke's justification for revolution is not based on mere discontent or disagreement but on the violation of fundamental rights. The right to revolution is a safeguard against oppression and ensures that government remains accountable to the people. This significantly influenced the American revolutionaries' justification for independence.

IV. Property and its Significance:

Locke dedicates considerable attention to the concept of property. He argues that individuals acquire property through their labor, mixing their work with natural resources. This right to property is fundamental, intimately connected to liberty and security.

Analysis: Locke's theory of property has been both praised and criticized. Critics argue it could justify the dispossession of indigenous populations, as Locke's concept of "mixing labor" with land might be interpreted to justify colonization. However, Locke also acknowledged limitations on property acquisition, suggesting that one should not take more than one can use without spoilage.

V. Separation of Powers (Implicit):

Although Locke doesn't explicitly advocate for a separation of powers in the same way Montesquieu later would, his emphasis on limited government and the protection of individual liberties suggests a preference for checks and balances. His emphasis on a legislature elected by the people hints at the need for a representative body to limit the power of the executive.

Analysis: Locke's ideas provided the conceptual foundation for later developments in constitutionalism, including the separation of powers. The American Founding Fathers, deeply influenced by Locke, incorporated these principles into the US Constitution, creating a system of checks and balances between the legislative, executive, and judicial branches.

VI. Lasting Influence:

Locke's Two Treatises profoundly impacted the development of Western political thought. Its influence can be seen in:

• The American Revolution: The Declaration of Independence echoes many of Locke's ideas about natural rights, the social contract, and the right to revolution.
• The Enlightenment: Locke's emphasis on reason, individual liberty, and limited government contributed to the broader Enlightenment project.
• Constitutionalism: The principles of limited government, the rule of law, and the protection of individual rights found in many modern constitutions are deeply indebted to Locke's work.
• Liberal Democracy: Locke's ideas helped lay the groundwork for the development of liberal democratic systems of government around the world.

Conclusion:

John Locke's Two Treatises of Government remains a powerful and relevant work of political philosophy. While some aspects of his theories, such as his concept of property, have been subject to criticism, his emphasis on natural rights, limited government, and the right to revolution continues to inspire political discourse and shape our understanding of justice and liberty. His work serves as a testament to the enduring power of ideas to shape the course of history. Further research into Locke's contemporaries and the historical context of his writings offers a richer understanding of the nuances and complexities of his political philosophy, making it a continuously debated and relevant topic in political science.