honey locust vs black locust

Championisme authors

3 min read

·

17-10-2024

19

0

Share

Honey Locust vs. Black Locust: A Detailed Comparison for Tree Enthusiasts

Choosing the right tree for your landscape can be a daunting task, especially when faced with similar species. Two trees often causing confusion are the Honey Locust (Gleditsia triacanthos) and the Black Locust (Robinia pseudoacacia). While they share some similarities, there are distinct differences that make them suitable for different applications. Let's delve into a head-to-head comparison, helping you decide which one is right for your needs.

1. Appearance and Growth Habits:

Honey Locust:

• Distinctive Thorns: Honey Locust is notorious for its long, sharp thorns, often growing in clusters. These formidable thorns can make pruning and maintenance challenging, but also act as a natural deterrent to wildlife.
• Feathery Foliage: The leaves are finely divided, resembling delicate ferns, giving the tree a light and airy appearance.
• Fast Growth: Honey Locust is a fast-growing tree, reaching heights of 70-100 feet with a spread of 40-50 feet.
• Trunk and Branching: It features a strong central trunk with spreading branches, forming a rounded crown.
• Fruit: Produces long, bean-like pods that hang from the branches, adding visual interest in the fall.

Black Locust:

• Thorns: Black Locust has shorter, more sporadic thorns, mainly located on young twigs.
• Compound Leaves: The leaves are composed of multiple leaflets, giving them a more substantial appearance than the Honey Locust's feathery foliage.
• Fast Growth: Like the Honey Locust, Black Locust is a fast-growing tree, reaching similar heights of 70-100 feet.
• Trunk and Branching: It typically develops a strong, straight trunk with upright branching, forming a more narrow, vase-shaped crown.
• Fruit: Produces flat, brown seedpods that are smaller than Honey Locust's pods.

2. Leaf Characteristics:

Honey Locust:

• Deciduous: Loses its leaves in the fall.
• Compound Leaves: Composed of numerous leaflets, giving a lacy, fern-like appearance.
• Leaflets: Small, oval-shaped leaflets with finely serrated margins.
• Color: Turns a lovely golden yellow in the fall.

Black Locust:

• Deciduous: Loses its leaves in the fall.
• Compound Leaves: Made up of 7 to 21 leaflets, giving a more robust appearance.
• Leaflets: Oval-shaped with smooth or slightly toothed margins.
• Color: Turns a bright yellow in the fall.

3. Flowering and Fruiting:

Honey Locust:

• Flowers: Fragrant, yellowish-green flowers appear in clusters in late spring.
• Fruit: Long, twisted pods that mature in late summer and hang throughout the winter, providing a unique visual element.

Black Locust:

• Flowers: Highly fragrant, white flowers appear in drooping clusters in late spring.
• Fruit: Flat, brown seedpods that mature in late summer and fall.

4. Hardiness and Adaptability:

Both trees are known for their resilience and adaptability to various soil conditions. However, there are some key differences:

Honey Locust:

• Hardiness Zones: Hardy in USDA zones 4-9.
• Soil Tolerance: Prefers well-drained soil, tolerates drought and alkaline conditions.
• Sun Exposure: Full sun to partial shade.

Black Locust:

• Hardiness Zones: Hardy in USDA zones 4-8.
• Soil Tolerance: Adaptable to a range of soil types, including poor, rocky soils.
• Sun Exposure: Full sun to partial shade.

5. Uses and Considerations:

Honey Locust:

• Street Trees: Often used as street trees due to its tolerance to pollution and difficult urban conditions.
• Shade Trees: Provides ample shade, making it ideal for parks and larger properties.
• Thornless Varieties: Thornless cultivars like 'Sunburst' and 'Imperial' are available, making them more suitable for areas where thorns are undesirable.
• Considerations: Thorns can be a safety hazard and require careful maintenance.

Black Locust:

• Lumber: The wood is exceptionally hard and durable, making it valuable for furniture, flooring, and fence posts.
• Nitrogen Fixer: A valuable nitrogen fixer, enriching the soil.
• Erosion Control: Effective in stabilizing slopes and preventing erosion.
• Considerations: The wood is prone to splitting and cracking, making it less desirable for fine woodworking.

Conclusion:

Choosing between Honey Locust and Black Locust depends on your specific needs and preferences. For a fast-growing, shade tree with stunning fall foliage, Honey Locust is a good option. However, be aware of the thorns and choose a thornless cultivar if necessary. Black Locust, with its hard wood and nitrogen-fixing capabilities, is well-suited for forestry and practical uses. Ultimately, understanding their distinct characteristics will help you make an informed decision about which tree is right for your landscape.

Disclaimer: This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute professional advice. Always consult with a qualified arborist or horticultural expert for specific tree selection and care recommendations.