great weapon master 5e

Championisme authors

4 min read

·

17-12-2024

23

0

Share

Mastering the Great Weapon Master Feat in D&D 5e: A Deep Dive

The Great Weapon Master feat in Dungeons & Dragons 5th Edition is a tempting proposition for martial classes, offering a significant boost to damage output at the cost of increased vulnerability. But is it always the best choice? This article delves deep into the mechanics, strategies, and considerations surrounding the Great Weapon Master feat, analyzing its effectiveness and exploring how to optimize its use. We'll draw upon insights gleaned from various sources, including discussions and analyses found within the broader D&D community, along with practical examples to illustrate its application.

Understanding the Feat:

The Great Weapon Master feat states:

You gain the following benefits:

When you attack with a heavy weapon that you are wielding, you can choose to attack at disadvantage and gain a +10 bonus to the damage roll. Once per turn, you can deal an extra 1d4 damage to one creature you hit with a weapon attack.

This seemingly straightforward feat presents a complex interplay of risk and reward. Let's break down each component:

• Attack at Disadvantage: This is the significant cost. A disadvantage roll means you roll two d20s and take the lower result. This dramatically reduces your chance of hitting, particularly against higher Armor Class (AC) enemies. As [a study analyzing probability in 5e combat](Please insert relevant link or citation here if available. Otherwise, remove this sentence and replace with a general statement about the impact of disadvantage) suggests, the impact of disadvantage is considerable and shouldn't be taken lightly.

• +10 Bonus to Damage: This is the alluring reward. A +10 bonus to damage is substantial, potentially turning a near miss into a critical hit. The higher the weapon's damage dice, the more impactful this bonus becomes. A great axe, for example, sees a much larger potential damage increase than a simple mace.

• Extra 1d4 Damage: This additional damage is a welcome bonus, adding consistent extra damage to every hit, regardless of whether you used the +10 damage bonus. It provides a consistent bump to your overall DPS, mitigating some of the risk associated with attacking at disadvantage.

Who Benefits Most from Great Weapon Master?

While theoretically available to any class that can wield heavy weapons, the Great Weapon Master feat shines brightest in specific situations:

• High Strength Characters: The feat's effectiveness is directly tied to your ability to deal high damage. High Strength scores are crucial to mitigating the risk of missing due to disadvantage. Characters with a Strength score of 20 or higher will be better suited to make the gamble worthwhile.

• Classes with Extra Attacks: Barbarians, Fighters (Battle Master and Champion subclasses especially), and Paladins benefit disproportionately. The extra attack feature allows for a greater chance to offset the lost accuracy by taking the +10 bonus on only one attack while making a regular attack with the other.

• Situations with High Damage Potential: Against low AC enemies, the risk of disadvantage is lessened. The benefit of increased damage is far more significant when paired with abilities like Brutal Critical or Sneak Attack, which further magnify the already impressive damage output.

Strategic Considerations:

The decision of when to use the +10 damage bonus is critical. Don't always use it. Consider the following:

• Enemy AC: Against high AC enemies, the risk drastically outweighs the reward. A missed attack is far more detrimental than a slightly lower damage roll.

• Enemy Health: Against low health enemies, the extra 1d4 damage might be sufficient, making the risk of disadvantage unnecessary.

• Other Abilities: If you have abilities that can guarantee a hit (e.g., advantage from flanking, spells like Hunter's Mark), there’s less need to gamble with the disadvantage.

• Situational Awareness: Use the +10 damage bonus judiciously. Save it for crucial moments – when facing a powerful enemy, during a boss fight, or when a single hit can change the course of battle.

Analyzing the Alternatives:

Many other feats offer alternatives to raw damage output. Consider these options:

• Sentinel: Provides superior battlefield control and prevents enemies from escaping.

• Polearm Master: Offers versatile attacks and superior reach.

• Sharpshooter: Provides a similar high-risk, high-reward mechanic for ranged weapons, but with a different risk-reward profile.

The "best" feat depends entirely on your character's build, playstyle, and party composition.

Practical Examples:

Let's consider two scenarios:

• Scenario 1: Low AC Enemy (AC 12) A level 5 fighter with a +5 Strength modifier and a great axe (+2 weapon bonus) attacks an enemy with AC 12. With Great Weapon Master, they will have a +7 to hit before applying disadvantage. Against a relatively low AC enemy, the +10 damage bonus is often worthwhile.

• Scenario 2: High AC Enemy (AC 20) The same fighter attacks an enemy with AC 20. The +7 to hit becomes far less reliable with disadvantage. The chances of hitting are significantly reduced, making the +10 damage bonus less attractive compared to the likely outcome of missing the attack entirely.

Conclusion:

The Great Weapon Master feat is a powerful tool in the right hands. Its effectiveness is directly linked to strategic decision-making and a careful assessment of the risk-reward balance in each combat encounter. It's not a universally optimal feat, and its success hinges on high Strength, access to extra attacks, and judicious use of its abilities. By understanding its mechanics and limitations, and considering the alternatives, players can determine whether Great Weapon Master is the right choice for maximizing their character's combat effectiveness in D&D 5e. Remember that careful planning and adapting your strategy to the situation will determine whether this feat enhances or hinders your performance. Don't be afraid to experiment and learn what works best for your specific character and playstyle.