geno smith vs baker mayfield

Championisme authors

2 min read

·

04-11-2024

24

0

Share

Geno Smith vs. Baker Mayfield: A Tale of Two Quarterbacks

The 2023 NFL season saw a resurgence of two quarterbacks who had previously faced doubts and criticism: Geno Smith and Baker Mayfield. Both signal-callers went from being seen as backups or even afterthoughts to leading their respective teams to unexpected success. But how do these two quarterbacks compare? Let's take a deep dive into their strengths, weaknesses, and the factors that contributed to their recent turnaround.

Geno Smith: From Doubt to Leader

After a tumultuous start to his career with the New York Jets, Geno Smith spent years bouncing around the league, fighting for playing time. But in 2022, with the Seattle Seahawks, he finally found a home. He stepped into the starting role after Russell Wilson's departure and led the team to a surprising playoff berth.

What Makes Geno Smith Tick?

• Improved Decision Making: A key factor in Smith's resurgence has been his improved decision-making. According to a study by Pro Football Focus (PFF), "Smith’s completion percentage over expectation (CPOE) in 2022 ranked in the top 10 among all quarterbacks." (PFF, 2022) This indicates that Smith is consistently making accurate throws and limiting costly turnovers.
• Accuracy & Deep Ball: Smith has always been known for his strong arm and ability to make throws downfield. This was on full display in 2022, as he connected on several big plays, including a 50-yard touchdown to DK Metcalf in a crucial Week 18 win.
• Leadership & Playmaking: Smith's leadership has also been instrumental in the Seahawks' success. He has instilled confidence in his teammates and has shown a willingness to make plays when needed.

Baker Mayfield: A Second Chance and Redemption

After a controversial departure from the Cleveland Browns, Baker Mayfield had a difficult 2022 season with the Carolina Panthers. But in 2023, he was given a fresh start with the Tampa Bay Buccaneers, filling the void left by Tom Brady's retirement.

What Makes Baker Mayfield Stand Out?

• Grit & Determination: Mayfield's competitive spirit and desire to prove his doubters wrong are undeniable. He has a reputation for being a tough and fearless player who is willing to fight for every inch. This was evident in his performance against the New Orleans Saints in Week 2, where he led the Buccaneers to victory despite playing through a shoulder injury.
• Pocket Presence & Improvisation: Mayfield is known for his ability to extend plays and make throws outside the pocket. This skillset is particularly valuable in the NFL, where defenses are constantly trying to disrupt the quarterback's rhythm.
• Clutch Performances: Mayfield has a history of performing well in high-pressure situations. This was evident in his time with the Browns, where he led the team to several comeback victories.

The Verdict: Who Wins This Battle?

Ultimately, both Geno Smith and Baker Mayfield have proven they have the talent and the determination to be successful in the NFL. Their recent success stories highlight the importance of opportunity and the resilience of these two quarterbacks.

Beyond the Stats:

While statistical comparisons are important, it's crucial to remember that both quarterbacks have faced unique challenges and opportunities. Smith benefited from a strong offensive line and a talented receiving corps in Seattle, while Mayfield had to adapt to a new team and a different offensive system in Tampa Bay.

A Final Thought:

The rivalry between Smith and Mayfield is a testament to the unpredictable nature of the NFL. Both players have overcome adversity and defied expectations, showing that it's never too late to make a comeback. As the 2023 season unfolds, it will be fascinating to see how these two quarterbacks continue to develop and what heights they can achieve.